The Spirit (Johansson, S. L. Jackson, Mendes, King, Vega, Dir. Frank Miller)

[editman]

That was disapointing. I Dont get why he choose to do it Sin Sity Style.

It's not the Sin City style. It's the Frank Miller visual style. And since he's the director, he can choose to do the film in his own style, can he?

The sad thing is, because Sin City did it first and successfully, any subsequent film done in the exact/similar fashion people would scream 'ripoff'. Well I say, if the suit fits the body, why not wear it again even if someone's been there and done that?

[jacques1400]

I actually like the "Sin City (Frank Miller)" style, and find it a good compromise between an extravagant CG loaded feature with cast, and a fully animated feature. I have to agree with Editman on this.

[Gaumont]

It's not the Sin City style. It's the Frank Miller visual style. And since he's the director, he can choose to do the film in his own style, can he?

It is Sin City style. Its what he´s used in all his sin city comics, and none of his other stuff. Sin City the movie, has nothing to do with it.

He got a different look for his Ronin, and a different look for Dark Knight. And Martha Washington, and electra, and 300 etc etc.

My point is, Frank Miller is really good at creating different styles. So re-using Sin City style is a shame, i would rather se something new, that im sure would be very cool.