A Knight's Tale
by Dean Kish
The sounds of the classic Queen song, “We Will Rock You” thunder as the camera drifts down
onto a medieval stadium. The people jamming the stadium beat their wooden seats and railings
as they chant to the lyrics of the song. From that pure instant you know very well this isn’t
going to be your typical medieval story about knights, honor, fair maidens, and dragons.
A Knight’s Tale tells the story of William Thatcher (Heath Ledger), a knight’s page who
dresses as a knight after his liege dies of old age. He learns that he isn’t that bad at
jousting and vows to become a knight even though he is forbidden to do so by law. For it is
written, that a man of noble birth can only become a knight.
With the help of struggling writer Geoff Chaucer (Paul Bettany), William adopts the identity
of Sir Ulrich von Lichenstein and vows to become the best knight in the land. Standing in
William’s way are the fair maiden, Jocelyn (Shannyn Sossamon) and the evil Count Adhemar
(Rufus Sewell).
“A Knight’s Tale” is a very original and interesting take on knights in cinema. Its drive is
centered in the charismatic performance of Heath Ledger, who helps ground the film in some
much needed sequences. Ledger definitely shows his leading man qualities in this project. He
will go a long way in Hollywood.
My favorite character in the film was Geoff Chaucer. As literature professionals know, the
real Geoffrey Chaucer was responsible for writing the “Canterbury Tales” which did chronicle a
lot of people of that day. The film’s incarnation is a brilliant humorous representative of
that figure. He has such command of the English language but he is also very human. Paul
Bettany’s Chaucer is a scene-stealer and I did really want to see more of his unique humor.
Placing Heath and Bettany aside, the main character of the film has to be the music. Having
people chant lyrics that were created hundreds of years after the events in the film and then
continuing with different songs throughout is very daring. I can see a lot of historians
throwing tomatoes at the screen and writing article upon article screaming outrage. What these
stuffy guys have to realize is that this is entertainment and popular music does grip the
sports world of today. As the film stated, “jousting” was the sport of that age and it gripped
nations. Every time we hear a face-off or a touchdown today, there is the thundering of a
sports anthem. I am not sure if back in the 14th Century they had their own sports chants or
ballads but I think if they were used here it may alienate the audience. Therefore I believe
the music brings us into William’s world and allows us to enjoy the challenge of jousting.
Don’t get me wrong but the film did have flaws within its originality. I found that the film
was at least 30 minutes to long and a supporting performance that was severely lacking.
The performance was the fair Jocelyn who for me was so clearly miscast. A lot of what she said
made me wonder what William ever saw in her. This performance made me really want to see a
real actress in the role. I mean she needed depth of emotion and inner turmoil to be shown on
the surface of her character to allow her love for William blossom. I also saw very little
chemistry between her and William. That was a real shame. Other problems with her were her
attire and hairstyle. It looked like she was a reject from the 1980s (ie: spiked “Joan Jett”
hair). The writers and the actress really needed to bring this character more depth and it
never was accomplished.
In the lagging 30 minutes, I really felt sorry for Rufus Sewell, who plays William’s
arch-enemy. The filmmakers used a lot of typical bad-guy stuff on William and that really
pulled away from the originality of the film. Sewell tries a lot to show the emotions within
the Count but he just doesn’t come through. Sewell is a good actor and this two-dimensional
role really doesn’t help him here.
A Knight’s Tale is a lot of fun if you don’t over analyze it. You will cheer and feel good
coming out. These aspects are all you need to enjoy for a summer movie.
(3.5 of 5) So Says the Soothsayer.
|