Unbreakable
by Dean Kish
Writer-director M Night Shyamalan creates another surreal journey. Will
this new film measure up to the imaginative plot and brilliant subtleness of
his previous film, "The Sixth Sense"?
Bruce Willis stars as David Dunn, a burnt-out ex-football hero who is
watching his home life melt in front of him. Dunn is returning to his home
via train when the train is involved in a horrendous train wreck. Dunn
awakens in a dimly lit hospital room where he is confronted by a doctor. The
doctor explains that it is a miracle that Dunn was able to walk away from
the train wreck unscathed and without a scratch. Dunn begins to show signs
of deep guilt and as he walks into the waiting room his son embraces him.
All the train wreck victims families watch as Dunn's son guides him out of
the hospital.
Days pass and Dunn's life really doesn't change except for the huge amount
of guilt placed on his shoulders. After attending the funeral for the train
wreck victims, Dunn opens a mysterious envelope on his windshield. The note
says, "How many days of your life have you been sick?" Doing a little
investigative work off the note, Dunn finds himself inside this comic book
art gallery called "Limited Edition". The name of the owner is Elijah Price
(Samuel L Jackson) and he asks Dunn some interesting questions. He also
tells him how much of a miracle it is to see a man walk away from a train
wreck. Price also speaks of his genetic condition where his bones break very
easily and his only true escape from that pain was the world of reading
comics. Price often uses comicbook references to describe the way society
operates stating that comics are often tales passed down like folktales of
old. What does this tortured man have to do with a train wreck survivor? Is
Dunn really a freak of nature? Is there logic to Elijah's thinking or are
these just fantastic stories?
A couple months back DC Comics released a small series of comics called
"Realworlds" which was a spin-off on their popular "Elseworlds" series. In
Realworlds, the essence of the hero-what it means to be a hero-comes
through, as truly human beings are inspired to a level of passion, nobility
and greatness worthy of the heroes themselves.
As I listened to the Price character talk to Dunn about the comics I
related back to the conception of what makes a hero and that "Realworld"
series. Was the Realworld concept being played in this film? In a lot of the
mysterious conversations between Price and Dunn we do have the concept
beginning to develop. But what I liked about Shyamalan's plot was the
reluctance of Dunn and Price's obsession. I loved how the script would
challenge the characters and the audience. Which character is right here?
The film has a great plot and some intriguing situations. However, I still
had some problems with the film's layout, and the eventual finale. I have
stated this before in some of my other reviews about the necessity of film
pacing. Shyamalan is infamous for putting together a very subtle story with
incredible circumstances. (ala the Sixth Sense) Personally, I think that
here he should have turned up the notch some. In the "Sixth Sense" subtly
was good as tried to enter the world of a boy. But in this film we really
needed some energy and in some circumstances I wanted the Price character to
interject with some much needed mysticism. For a lot of the film, I was
wondering when it was going to pick up. I really liked the character of
Elijah Price more than the Dunn character. I could feel for Elijah and I
think the stairs scene was the key to showing this man's struggle. Seeing
the depth of the Price character, I asked myself would the Dunn character
have been more intriguing if he was a cop instead of a security guard? Or
was Shyamalan aiming for extreme subtlety in Dunn.
As the film concludes I felt a little dismayed that it ended so abruptly.
Was the end rushed in hopes that audiences will return to see if there
unanswered questions were found in the film. (ala the Sixth Sense) And what
exactly is Dunn? Write me here if you think you know.
Trying to live up to the intensity of the "Sixth Sense" is kind of like
what happened with Blair Witch 2 earlier this year. It's impossible to carry
on the same feeling from the previous film without telling the same story
again. Unbreakable looks and feels very much the same as the "Sixth Sense"
but internally it's vastly different.
(3.5 of 5) So Says the Soothsayer.
Unbreakable
by Geoff Ross
Elijah Price was born with a rare genetic bone disorder that makes his skeleton very brittle
and prone to breakage. As a child growing up in Philadelphia kids used to call him Mr.
Glass. Through all of his torment and pain the now adult Elijah Price had developed a theory,
if there was someone on this planet as brittle as himself shouldn't there be someone on the
other end of the spectrum who was virtually indestructible? One day there was an incredibly
bad train wreck in which everyone who was on board perished horribly except for one man,
David Dunn, who left without a scratch on him. David Dunn, according to Price, is the man
who can't be broken. Price, an avid collector of comic book art, is convinced that Dunn was
put on this Earth for a higher purpose than the one he's currently living and Price makes it
his goal to convince David Dunn of his almost super abilities.
Plot: Wow....wow. M. Night. Shyamalan, director/writer of The Sixth Sense, has a talent for
writing engaging stories with simple down-to-Earth characters and Unbreakable continues with
this trend. First and foremost this film is NOT The Sixth Sense. Yes both movies share a
similar visual style, but Unbreakable is not a creepy psychological horror picture, its a
beautifully crafted reluctant hero story that manages to pull the audience into the movie's
slightly augmented reality. As with Shyamalan's other work this movie also contains a plot
twist at the end albeit not a shocking as the one in The Sixth Sense it still forces the
audiences to reevaluate the entire movie. In my personal opinion Shyamalan deserved the $5
million, most ever for a screenplay, that the studio paid him for this film. The plot is so
intriguing, it's like a comic book deeply set in the roots of reality. Shyamalan has a great
talent for writing and I can't wait to see what he has in store next. *****(out of five)
Acting: The character Elijah Price could break at any moment one small spill and every bone
in his body would be shattered, needless to say a character who is constantly in pain would
be hard to play, but Samuel L. Jackson does the role like he was born for it. He creates this
incredibly powerful personality in the frailest of bodies. In every scene Jackson creates
this sense of constant anguish being battled every moment, truly astonishing. I never felt
so personally attached to a film character in my life. The performance was simply astounding.
The reluctant hero of David Dunn is similar in many was to John McClane, from the Die Hard
series, James Cole, form Twelve monkeys, Major Korben Dallas, from The Fifth Element, and
even Dr. Malcolm Crowe, from the Sixth Sense. Of course Bruce Willis plays the tortured hero
role well, but his done it before (at least 4 times before if not more). Plus, his
performance in Unbreakable isn't nearly as good as his performance in Twelve Monkeys
(Which was also set in Philadelphia like Unbreakable and The Sixth Sense). Then again
this film would be nothing without Willis' strong performance so in that sense he did a
fantastic job. For audience members who are looking for the next Haley Joel Osmet you're
going to be disappointed. Although Spencer Treat Clark does a great job playing David Dunn's
son Joseph he isn't the same kind of actor that Osmet is plus his character isn't as vital to
the storyline as Osmet's was in The Sixth Sense. ****1/2(out of five)
Directing: M. Night Shyamalan (An NYU film graduate for those who are keeping track) is a
truly talented individual. His filmmaking style in this film is even more refined than that
of his work in the Sixth Sense...which was an excellent directing job in the first place.
Shyamalan wields the film camera like Michelangelo wields a brush, premeditated perfection.
The kind of emotion that the imagery ALONE invokes is the stuff of text books for film
students, this is how true drama should be. Every single movement of the lens is done for
a purpose not just for flair or wow-factor, but for art. Shyamalan is able to invoke career
best performances out of his actors., expect to hear this films name around Academy Award
time. The whole film is composed to perfection. Thoroughly enjoyable. *****(out of five)
Music: Unbreakable is composer James Newton Howard's 82nd film since his first major score in
1986. Ever since the days when Howard dropped out of USC's prestigious music program (USC's
Film program is the biggest rival and perhaps superior to NYU's film program) to tour with
Elton John he has been making great scores. Any audience members who have seen The Sixth
Sense will immediately recognize the style of Unbreakable (Howard composed The Sixth Sense),
but what the score to Unbreakable does that the score to Sixth Sense did not was create a
recognizable consistent theme. The emotionally jarring score to this film is the perfect
supplement to the performances on screen, even after 82 films Howard has not lost sight of
what he is composing. If only it wasn't so similar to The Sixth Sense. ****(out of five)
Special Effects: Unbreakable is not an effects film. Yes there were effects in the movie,
but this film was definitely plot-driven and the special effects reflect that. The Secret
lab, formerly Dream quest Images, headed up the effects for this film creating an eerie memory
visual for all of the journeys into the mind. Hard to describe, but extremely effective.
The majority of their work consisted of invisible effects (Composites, wire removal, color
correction, etc.). All in all a good effort. ****(out of five)
Bottom Line: Unbreakable is NOT The Sixth Sense, but it stands proudly by itself
nonetheless. Not a family film, but great for teenagers and adults alike. ****1/2(out of five)
|