So it's finally come to this. No matter how violent, aggressive and misogynist many of our beloved American comic books and Japanese manga are, it's Tintin who gets sued for being racist. The first book, published a decade before WWII (!), is now the subject of debate. Was it indeed colonialist? Did it have fascist leanings?
I can honestly understand that certain images would appear inappropriate to audiences today, but over 70 years ago, the world was different. Depictions of the Belgian Congo, like the following one:
were pretty normal and hardly perceived as racist.
Yet no matter what, certain people want to have the comic book banned, from the children department by some, from existence by others. Now this is where I must protest:
1) It's censorship. You like that? Go to Russia, 20 years ago. I'm against it.
2) Smart people understand that those images are not at all meant to be taken seriously. It's a comic book, people! Why don't you burn down our embassy?
3) It was published more than 70 years ago! What's the point? Next thing a bunch of feminists is going to sue the Bible for its explicit advise to stone women who commit adultery.
4) Hergé meant no harm. Plus, he's not the only one. I can think of a dozen more European comic books that would have to be banned then.
Anyway, they ain't gonna get my copy. And besides, the book features talking dog's, lions, monkeys and alligators. Who even takes that material seriously? Wow, yes I can feel the racist propaganda flowing through my veins… :roll:
If people want tolerance, why don't they start with showing a little bit of that themselves. Especially when it comes to humor.
By the way, the original book has already been 'cleaned' once. For example. In the following picture, the old one is matched up against the 'new' one. So they replaced a black man by a Greek man and now everybody is happy :shock::
Look, I'm neither racist, colonialist, fascist nor misogynist, but I do believe that we're crossing a dangerous line by attacking art from the old days on its 'unacceptable content' today. What do you think?
Bookmarks